Follow by Email

Friday, 27 January 2017

Danzig Unmasks the Impotence of the League of Nations


The League of Nations was entering its death throes as was painfully obvious from the latest deliberations over the Free State of Danzig, an island of ethnic German territory surrounded by Poland, theoretically controlled by the League. The League’s Committee of Three which had been given oversight of the issue – Britain, France and Sweden – all but admitted that the situation was desperate, when faced with the question of settling grievances between the Poles and the Danzigers. It was simply accepted that the process would be a bilateral one, although the elephant in the room – Nazi Germany – was ignored. Danzig’s autonomy was largely fictional and, in practice, Berlin would make the decisions. Two and a half years later, Berlin took the decisions that caused the Second World War.

The British government was once again taken to task In Parliament for the slow pace of air rearmament with Sir Thomas Inskip, displaying once again his weaknesses as Minister for Coordination of Defence. His point that re-equipment of bombers squadrons with modern machines represented a major increase in their effective value, was perfectly valid, but it was not sufficiently strong to defeat the House’s obsession with a crude numbers game. The quantum leap in technology helped explain the painful delay in expansion of output. Mercifully for the government, Winston Churchill made only gentle criticism. He was still recovering from the Parliamentary mauling that he had suffered for his unwise support of Edward VIII and had good reason to avoid the risk of a repetition.


Spectacular storms swept over the North Sea with numerous fatal shipwrecks and damage on land.

Friday, 20 January 2017

FDR and Stalin: A contrast in degree of power


Franklin D. Roosevelt was elected for his second term as US President, having been elected with a landslide victory. He hoped to translate this win into a concrete increase in his own powers within the US constitution. He hoped to weaken the power of Congress and the Supreme Court to dilute his instinct to in favour of radical policies at home and more active diplomacy abroad. It would be a long struggle. The weakness of his underlying position can be read in the argument his side advanced for any change. To claim that the floods then devastating Ohio proved that the executive needed stronger powers, was hardly convincing.

The British War Minister, Duff Cooper, upped the debate on rebuilding military strength by a piece of pre-emptive concession. He publicly ruled out introducing conscription in time of peace. This was not a great sacrifice given the overwhelming opposition that any such measure would face. Even in 1939 when Hitler’s occupation of Bohemia made war practically inevitable, only a mild, diluted and disguised scheme was brought in. By pronouncing the dread word publicly, Duff Cooper signalled his belief in the dangers of the international situation. It was not an agreeable notion for his more conservative colleagues.


Stalin had far from exhausted the supply of high profile figures from the Revolutionary past to butcher. Save a clutch of loyal nonentities, anybody who had done anything to bring him to public notice had committed the sin of challenging the Man of Steel’s status. Another shift of show trials was announced. This time the net extended to distinguished foreigners, in particular the German Karl Radek. Perhaps in deference to this status, he was let off with a trivial ten years in the Gulag. Radek was also a Jew, but it is unclear if Stalin wanted to display solidarity with his colleague in dictatorship, but purported ideological opponent, Adolf Hitler.

Friday, 13 January 2017

Tokenism in Diplomacy, Title Inflation at the Abbey


The pattern of foreign involvement in the Spanish Civil War continued to repeat itself as steps were taken to try to control the participation of foreigners in the war. Britain and France were keen to curb the arrival of “volunteers” from the Fascist powers, but wholly lacking in any leverage to achieve this or resolution in trying to do so. Germany fobbed them off with a supportively phrased, but quite empty reply. In a pitiable attempt to set a good example, Britain and France paraded their own efforts. Britain promised to apply the Foreign Enlistment Act of 1870 vigorously to Spain and France more vaguely promised legislation.

In Italy respect for Fascist forms was reinforced when Achille Starace, Secretary of the Fascist Party and the nearest thing Mussolini had to an ideologue, renewed his call that the official ban on traditional hand-shakes should be respected. Such a conservative, bourgeois gesture betrayed “scanty fascist spirit”. The official Fascist salute approximated to the Hitlergru├č, albeit delivered with far less precision and military aplomb.


British Palace officials wrestled with the problem of allocating seats in Westminster Abbey for the Coronation in May. They were dogged by a factor as potent then as it is today: the inflation in the number of individuals on whom the powers that be had conferred the status of being a distinguished individual. Compared to the Coronation of George V in 1911, there were sixty extra Privy Councillors (generally ministers and ex-ministers) and no fewer than 200 extra Knights Grand Cross, the top tier of each order of knighthood, usually awarded to military men and civil servants.

Friday, 6 January 2017

A Blast from France's Political Past and a Foretaste of the Spanish Republic's Evil Future


As 1936 turned into 1937 a figure from a bygone age, who had already come back from two near-death experiences, made his final impact on French politics. Joseph Caillaux had ridden out an immense scandal when his wife murdered Henri Calmette, editor of the Figaro newspaper, in 1914 when it published some of her indiscreet correspondence, only to be jailed in 1917 on a tenuous charge of  treason, in reality because of his political campaign for negotiated peace with Germany. By 1936 he had become a Senator and forced the Front Populaire government to modify its budget for 1937 in a cliff-hanger session, that left it technical spending money illegally.

The expulsion of the Trotskyite POUM faction from the Catalan government in Republican Spain  provided a foretaste of the bitter, and ultimately bloody, factional internecine battles of the far left. This was the work of the Stalinists, who were increasingly the dominant force on the Republican side, and the conduit for the only source of serious international support. Ultimately, they devoted more effort to the extermination of the POUM than fighting the Nationalists.


The slow recovery of the US economy from the ravages of the Great Depression made itself felt perversely in yet another massive strike by General Motors workers, keen to share the fruits of improved demand. With twelve plants already shut down, the corporation’s management predicted that 135,000 workers would soon be idle.